My daughter recently appeared in The Wiz, an updated, musical retelling of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. While the story is similar to the original, all of the music is different, and contains a distinct mid-1970s urban, disco feel. It’s a trip.
In one scene, the Wicked Witch of the West, named Evilene, sings a song called, “Don’t Nobody Bring Me No Bad News.” Watch this clip on YouTube to get a flavor (don’t worry, there’s a point to be made here):
Before The Wiz ever hit Broadway, Shakespeare was penning these words for his play Henry IV: “Come hither, sir. Though it be honest, it is never good to bring bad news.” Before that, the Greek philosopher and writer, Sophocles, created this dialogue for his character Antigone, “No one loves the messenger who brings bad news.”
Bring Your Client Bad News
Some of you may think it’s your job to always keep the client happy. You think a successful client relationship is one where everyone is always smiling. In other words, don’t nobody bring me no bad news.
You might even avoid bringing in that smarty-pants from the Headquarters Products Group because she’s always stirring the pot, challenging the client, pushing them to think differently. You don’t want her to “screw up the relationship.”
Then, one day, you are caught completely off-guard when you hear that your great client is piloting a concept with one of your competitors. “Don’t worry,” you’re told, “it’s just a small side project the senior executives asked for because they were at some conference and heard about a new approach that supposedly addresses some problems we didn’t even know needed fixing.”
What just happened?
Deliberately Provoking the Client
Someone else was willing to challenge your customer’s status quo. Someone other than you was able to get the senior executives’ attention by telling them something they didn’t know, about a problem they didn’t know they had.
In other words, they were able to gain strategic executive altitude and wrest your client’s attention away from you by bringing them some bad news:
- They were willing to push the customer out of their comfort zone.
- They helped the customer see their competitive challenges in a new light.
- They highlighted specific painful situations and made them unmistakably urgent.
- They had the guts to create constructive tension and use it to their advantage.
This is counter-intuitive to many companies and salespeople, who are afraid the customer will shoot the messenger. And, put all of your current business at risk.
Throughout history messengers have been vulnerable to attack. In ancient war times, news would be carried by fast runners, who would be sent to battle fronts to report back on victory or defeat, or to request reinforcements. If the news was not good, and the receiver chose to vent their anger, these messengers could meet an untimely and violent death.
But in today’s hyper-competitive, increasingly complex selling environments, where you need to cut through the clutter of sameness and overcome the rise of risk aversion to get your customer to care about your message, you might have to be the bearer of a little bad news.
A March 2009 Harvard Business Review article titled, “In a Downturn, Provoke Your Customers,” captured the essence of this concept and coined the phrase “provocation-based selling.”
Briefly stated, the provocation concept contained three components:
- Identify a critical problem facing your customer – one so ominous that, even in a downturn, they will find the money to address it. Critical problems meet the following criteria: they seriously jeopardize your customers’ ability to compete, they’ve proved stubborn to solve, and you are a credible source of advice on them.
- Formulate a provocative view of the problem – a fresh perspective that frames the problem in a jarring new light. Rather than finding out how your client’s executives currently view the problem you’ve identified, you determine how they should view it and deliver insight around it.
- Lodge your provocation – to win support, convey the magnitude, difficulty and urgency of the problem with an executive who has the power to approve the solution you’re proposing – without putting him on the defensive. First, you may have to convince a sponsor/referrer of the idea and get them to make an introduction.
During the early “Warring States” period of China, the concept of chivalry and virtue prevented the executions of messengers sent by opposing sides. This continued as an invisible code of conduct in war where a commanding officer was expected to receive and send back emissaries or diplomatic envoys sent by the enemy unharmed.
Today, your customers are essentially saying, “If you want my attention, tell me something I don’t already know, about a problem I didn’t even know I had.”
They aren’t looking to shoot the messenger. Take your messenger role seriously. Provoking and challenging your customer will be rewarded.
By Tim Riesterer
CMO and SVP Strategic Consulting at Corporate Visions Inc.
Co-author of Customer Message Management